US Copyright Act Is Claimed to Be Used Against Ad Blocking

16 August 2017

An event on 10 August has stirred a renewed attention to the ad blocking issue. The blocking side accused a company of using US copyright law to push through its ads.

What exactly happened?

A domain named “functionalclam.com” was excluded from the EasyList – a popular register of domains used by ad blockers – after a DMCA takedown request had been made.

• DMCA is the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, an act that protects copyright infringement on the Internet.
• DMCA takedown request is generally understood as a request of a content owner to remove their content from the source infringing owner’s rights.

Typically, such a request is used for deleting links to the pirated music or movies. And so, the domain owner’s move raised a question if the Act can be applicable for domain names at all. For ad blockers, this could mean an ultimate inability to use domain lists. Domain names, however, do not fall under the Act, as US Copyright Office states.

Later, the domain functionalclam.com appeared to be owned by Admiral – a company fighting the ad blocking. It contains the message saying it is used by publishers for controlling access to their copyrighted content.

Digital publishing basics

Initial message on the unblocked domain

Company’s CEO Dan Rua has made an official statement, which was supposed to explain why the DMCA was used.

He states the domain is used not for ad serving, but for the access control to copyrighted content. To put it simply, they work on mechanisms for publishers to ask or motivate users to whitelist the website or pay for accessing it. As Admiral explains, DMCA is applicable in terms of Act’s part about “technological measure circumvention”. Thus, functionalclam.com being blocked means deactivating a control tool of content owners.
Official comment of EasyList on this states, if it’s a circumvention issue, the domain had to be removed even before the DMCA request.

Still, the problem exists

In the past, there have already been a discussion on applying DMCA to the Adblock Plus. Say, a website starts using anti-adblocking tools. If Adblock Plus tries to roll out a countermeasure, theoretically it makes such step a circumvention of a tool used for content control.

Main message on Admiral’s website

The main question now is whether the situation with “functionalclam.com” will become a paved way for other websites or actual advertising companies to file copyright complaints and fight the ad blocking.

Want to learn more?

    Select
    Demand
    Brand
    Agency
    DSP
    Supply
    Web Publisher
    App Developer
    SSP
    Media House
    Others
    Ad Network Owner
    Tech Vendor
    Other/Not Sure
    You Might Also Like
    How Life-Extension of 3P Cookies Will Affect the Industry? - Admixer blog

    On 24 June 2021, Google once again grabbed the spotlight to announce that it has delayed a major privacy change to its Chrome browser. Google is postponing a plan to block third-party cookies until late 2023.   The official reasoning behind the decision — is the need to test sustainable alternatives that do not violate user […]

    How the delay in 3p cookies phase out will affect adtech industry? - Admixer blog
    Die Another Day: How Life-Extension of 3P Cookies Will Affect the Industry?

    On 24 June 2021, Google once again grabbed the spotlight to announce that it has delayed a major privacy change to its Chrome browser. Google is postponing a plan to block third-party cookies until late 2023.   The official reasoning behind the decision — is the need to test sustainable alternatives that do not violate user […]

    Read more
    Device fingerprinting - Admixer Blog

    Device fingerprinting, or you may have heard of it as web fingerprinting, mobile device fingerprinting, browser fingerprinting, or machine fingerprinting, has a concept similar to collecting human fingerprints by a detective, but not so obvious. With 3rd-party cookies soon becoming obsolete, fingerprinting will be one of the cookie alternatives that will help marketers target users […]

    Device fingerprint - hover image - Admixer Blog
    Device Fingerprinting: Pros and Cons of the Controversial Method

    Device fingerprinting, or you may have heard of it as web fingerprinting, mobile device fingerprinting, browser fingerprinting, or machine fingerprinting, has a concept similar to collecting human fingerprints by a detective, but not so obvious. With 3rd-party cookies soon becoming obsolete, fingerprinting will be one of the cookie alternatives that will help marketers target users […]

    Read more
    Identity Graph - Admixer Blog

    Marketers are facing an identity crisis propelled by cookies turning obsolete and Apple’s ATT coming into force. In light of the fading addressability, the identity graph provides time-honored stability as well as new exciting opportunities.  With the rise of people-oriented marketing, identity graphs have become the foundation of identifying people across channels and devices. They […]

    User Identity Graph - Admixer Blog
    Identity Graph: What Is in It for Marketing?

    Marketers are facing an identity crisis propelled by cookies turning obsolete and Apple’s ATT coming into force. In light of the fading addressability, the identity graph provides time-honored stability as well as new exciting opportunities.  With the rise of people-oriented marketing, identity graphs have become the foundation of identifying people across channels and devices. They […]

    Read more

      Stay updated with Admixer
      Privacy Policy