First-price ad auction plays first fiddle

11 October 2017

A number of ad exchanges announced they will open the info on the type of ad auction publishers bid in. Why is it even a problem? And what’s the difference between auction types? Let’s dive in.

Ad exchanges use two ad auction types – first-price and second-price

The waterfall ad buying works by the second-price model. Header Bidding works by the first-price model.
The bidder with the highest bid wins. The bidder with the highest bid wins.
The winner pays the price submitted by the second highest bidder plus one penny. The winner pays the highest submitted price.
auction types

Picture: Admixer


An ad auction is performed based on OpenRTB protocol. When user visits a website, requests for bids are sent to buyers, so that they can bid on this opportunity for a user to see their ad. And their bidding strategies for two ad auction types differ greatly.

rtb

Bid request’s place on RTB sequence scheme

Such bid request has a unified structure, determined by IAB standards. The standard of a bid request includes the line, where the auction type is mentioned. Not all participants of ad buying process get these data. A number of ad exchanges led by OpenX want to bring more openness to the process of bidding on inventory. Their initial offer was to prioritize the first-price model and disclose the auction type to the participants.

request

Auction type line in a bid request

The initiative pushed by ad exchanges was to make this variable of a bid request always known to buyers. It wasn’t open before for two reasons. The second-price model has been the primer one for a long time. And when the first-price auction type got popular, some platforms started mixing the two to get their hidden gains.


The idea behind second-price auctions

Closed bids make buyers reflect on an actual price for the inventory. Publishers believed buyers can underestimate its true value. So they liked the idea of a second-price auctioning.

If all bids in second-price auction were known, it wouldn’t make any sense. Everyone could just add a penny to the highest price and win.

In an actual second-price auction, the bids of others are closed. This creates a positive effect. It makes all buyers think of how much they are willing to pay for the lot.

The pitfalls of a second-price auction

Since all bids are closed, everything a buyer gets is a notification of winning a deal. An ad exchange passes forward the final clearing price and not all bids.

This creates different ways for ad exchanges to counterfeit the auction flaw:

  • submitting fake bids
  • faking clearing prices
  • setting high floor prices

Ad exchanges are able to change the clearing price, so that a winner pays the price almost as high as the first one. There’s the price difference between the second and the first highest prices. The second price is supposed to be raised by one cent only. In fact, if the highest price is 6 USD and the second price is 4 USD, ad exchanges are able to set the price in a range between 4.01 and 5.99.

price floor

Picture: Digiday

Admixer’s main business is publisher’s wealth. We care both about the growth of income for our direct clients and overall transparency between industry actors. We support the initiative to make ad auction type known to everyone. Admixer is also heading towards first-price auctioning.

“The second-price auction leaves the space for deception and overpricing. The first-price model creates the dynamic change of bids to ensure a fair and competitive auction,” says Admixer CEO Aleksey Boltivets.

At the moment, we are busy discussing the issue with our partners. Follow our news for the future additional announcements.

Want to learn more?

    Select
    Demand
    Brand
    Agency
    DSP
    Supply
    Web Publisher
    App Developer
    SSP
    Media House
    Others
    Ad Network Owner
    Tech Vendor
    Other/Not Sure
    You Might Also Like
    How Life-Extension of 3P Cookies Will Affect the Industry? - Admixer blog

    On 24 June 2021, Google once again grabbed the spotlight to announce that it has delayed a major privacy change to its Chrome browser. Google is postponing a plan to block third-party cookies until late 2023.   The official reasoning behind the decision — is the need to test sustainable alternatives that do not violate user […]

    How the delay in 3p cookies phase out will affect adtech industry? - Admixer blog
    Die Another Day: How Life-Extension of 3P Cookies Will Affect the Industry?

    On 24 June 2021, Google once again grabbed the spotlight to announce that it has delayed a major privacy change to its Chrome browser. Google is postponing a plan to block third-party cookies until late 2023.   The official reasoning behind the decision — is the need to test sustainable alternatives that do not violate user […]

    Read more
    Device fingerprinting - Admixer Blog

    Device fingerprinting, or you may have heard of it as web fingerprinting, mobile device fingerprinting, browser fingerprinting, or machine fingerprinting, has a concept similar to collecting human fingerprints by a detective, but not so obvious. With 3rd-party cookies soon becoming obsolete, fingerprinting will be one of the cookie alternatives that will help marketers target users […]

    Device fingerprint - hover image - Admixer Blog
    Device Fingerprinting: Pros and Cons of the Controversial Method

    Device fingerprinting, or you may have heard of it as web fingerprinting, mobile device fingerprinting, browser fingerprinting, or machine fingerprinting, has a concept similar to collecting human fingerprints by a detective, but not so obvious. With 3rd-party cookies soon becoming obsolete, fingerprinting will be one of the cookie alternatives that will help marketers target users […]

    Read more
    Identity Graph - Admixer Blog

    Marketers are facing an identity crisis propelled by cookies turning obsolete and Apple’s ATT coming into force. In light of the fading addressability, the identity graph provides time-honored stability as well as new exciting opportunities.  With the rise of people-oriented marketing, identity graphs have become the foundation of identifying people across channels and devices. They […]

    User Identity Graph - Admixer Blog
    Identity Graph: What Is in It for Marketing?

    Marketers are facing an identity crisis propelled by cookies turning obsolete and Apple’s ATT coming into force. In light of the fading addressability, the identity graph provides time-honored stability as well as new exciting opportunities.  With the rise of people-oriented marketing, identity graphs have become the foundation of identifying people across channels and devices. They […]

    Read more

      Stay updated with Admixer
      Privacy Policy